The FX Replay alternative that also keeps your journal.

Backtest real prop firm programs with their own rules, phases and payouts, replay your live trades blind, and see every trade from MetaTrader, TopstepX or your crypto exchange in the same app. One price, everything included.

21 features compared. 17 of them are missing or limited in FX Replay.

nuchtr and FX Replay, point by point.

nuchtrFX Replay
Price and plan
Price per month€29.95 per 30 days incl. VAT, one plan with everythingFree, Intermediate $17.99, Pro $35
Everything in one planYesProp simulator from Intermediate, seconds and futures data on Pro
Prop firms
Real prop firm programs with their rules74 named programsYou type the rules yourself
Phases and requesting a payout in the backtestYesPass or fail with a certificate
Prop firm fees against payouts (ROI)YesNo
Room to your drawdown on your real funded accountsYesOnly inside simulated sessions
Backtesting
Candle replay on real market dataYesYes
News calendar inside the backtesterYesYes
Replay your own live trades, blindYesOnly backtest trades
Journal and sync
MetaTrader 4 and 5AutomaticWhen you click sync
TopstepXYesCSV upload
NinjaTrader, Tradovate and RithmicYesNinjaTrader and Tradovate, Rithmic not listed
Crypto exchanges auto syncBybit, OKX, Binance, Bitget, Kraken, KuCoin, MEXC, Coinbase and HyperliquidNo
Rules per trade, with your follow rate and streaksYesA checklist per trade, no adherence stats
Monthly report from your own dataYesAI feedback on backtests, no monthly report
Beyond trading
Net worth trackerYesNo
GoalsYesA practice streak
Accountability partner (a real person)YesNo, the mentor is an AI
Share cards anyone can verify with a QR codeYesA read only link and a challenge certificate
Costs and bookkeeping, export for your accountantYesNo
Coach access to your journalYesNo

Prices and features of FX Replay from its own website (pricing, prop firm simulator, trading journal, trading accounts, FAQ), checked point by point on 3 November 2026. "No" means we could not find it on their official pricing, feature or help pages. FX Replay prices in USD as shown there. FX Replay is a trademark of its owner. nuchtr is not affiliated with FX Replay.

What you only get in nuchtr.

74 real prop firm programs. In the nuchtr app.
Only in nuchtr

74 real prop firm programs.

FTMO, Topstep, Apex, FundedNext, The5ers and more, each with its own rules, phases and fees. No typing in rules yourself.

All the way to your payout. In the nuchtr app.
Only in nuchtr

All the way to your payout.

Pass the phases and request your payout like on a live account, then see your fee come back.

Your real ROI. In the nuchtr app.
Only in nuchtr

Your real ROI.

What every prop firm cost you against what came back, per firm and in total.

Replay your live trades, blind. In the nuchtr app.
Only in nuchtr

Replay your live trades, blind.

Your synced trades go straight into the backtester. The outcome stays hidden until you decide.

Your net worth. In the nuchtr app.
Only in nuchtr

Your net worth.

Follow your payouts into your wealth, with crypto, stocks and cash together.

A trading buddy. In the nuchtr app.
Only in nuchtr

A trading buddy.

A real accountability partner who sees how well you keep your rules, never your amounts.

Questions

Is nuchtr a good FX Replay alternative?

Yes, if you want backtesting and more. nuchtr backtests on real market data candle by candle, plays 74 real prop firm programs with their own rules up to the payout, and also keeps your trading journal, your real ROI and your net worth in the same app.

How does the price compare?

nuchtr is €29.95 every 30 days including VAT (€24.75 excluding VAT for businesses) with every feature included. FX Replay lists Pro at $35 a month and Intermediate at $17.99 a month with limits.

What does nuchtr have that FX Replay does not?

Named prop firm programs with their rules, phases and payouts, prop firm ROI, blind replay of your own live trades, crypto exchange and TopstepX sync, a net worth tracker, goals, a human accountability partner, coach access and bookkeeping exports.

Does nuchtr work with my platform?

MetaTrader 4 and 5 through a small EA, TopstepX through your ProjectX API key, NinjaTrader with Tradovate and Rithmic through a bridge, and Bybit, OKX, Binance, Bitget, Kraken, KuCoin, MEXC, Coinbase and Hyperliquid. You can also import a CSV.

Backtest, journal and get paid out. In one app.

Your journal, backtesting, prop firms and net worth in one app. Monthly, cancel any time.

Start 7 days free